Draft

Draft value

Approximate Value is Pro Football Reference's single number for a season. Weighted career AV, written wAV, counts a player's best seasons more than the rest. nflverse publishes it on every draft pick. It is a blunt grade: an offensive lineman is credited through the whole offense, and a long career outscores a short one. It is also the same public scale for every position, which is what makes a pick-by-pick curve possible.

Hit rates and the curve use draft classes 2005 through 2018, 3,563 picks. A player from 2018 had at least 7 seasons to build a career. Classes after 2018 are left out. A recent pick has not had time to fail or to last, and counting that unfinished career would make the later rounds look worse than they are.

Value over slot

Steals and busts

Value over slot is career weighted AV minus the wAV this pick was worth on the 2005–2018 curve. Steals are the top of that list. Busts are the bottom. The default list stops at 2018, so a short career is not graded as a finished one.

8,997 of 12,927 draft picks matched an ESPN player id, from the nflverse players file, on gsis or PFR id plus last name. A pick that did not match is still listed, without a link. A player matched to two drafts has no badge on his page. 2026 has no published wAV yet, so that class is left out.

Opening the leaderboard…

2005–2018

By round

  • Round 1

    446 picks

    Mean wAV
    43.7
    Median wAV
    40.0
    3+ seasons as starter
    77.6%
    1+ Pro Bowl
    45.7%
  • Round 2

    445 picks

    Mean wAV
    28.0
    Median wAV
    23.0
    3+ seasons as starter
    56.6%
    1+ Pro Bowl
    21.6%
  • Round 3

    496 picks

    Mean wAV
    19.5
    Median wAV
    12.0
    3+ seasons as starter
    37.9%
    1+ Pro Bowl
    12.1%
  • Round 4

    516 picks

    Mean wAV
    14.8
    Median wAV
    8.5
    3+ seasons as starter
    24.8%
    1+ Pro Bowl
    8.3%
  • Round 5

    510 picks

    Mean wAV
    10.7
    Median wAV
    4.0
    3+ seasons as starter
    20.6%
    1+ Pro Bowl
    6.5%
  • Round 6

    547 picks

    Mean wAV
    7.7
    Median wAV
    2.0
    3+ seasons as starter
    13.2%
    1+ Pro Bowl
    3.8%
  • Round 7

    603 picks

    Mean wAV
    5.9
    Median wAV
    1.0
    3+ seasons as starter
    8.8%
    1+ Pro Bowl
    2.3%

A starter season is one with a start, from nflverse seasons_started. Pro Bowl means at least one selection. Missing AV, starts, and Pro Bowls count as zero.

Pick 1 = 100

By pick

The line is a log fit on those same careers: wAV = 76.19 −12.88 × ln(pick). The printed coefficients are rounded to two decimals. The line uses the full least-squares fit, which puts pick 32 at 41.4% of pick 1.

A raw average of the same picks: picks 1–3 mean 60.2 wAV and picks 31–35 mean 36.2, 60.2% of the top of the round. The smoothed line is lower at pick 32 because the first pick sits above the next few. This is one curve for every position, with age left out.

  • Pick 32 · Teamistry

    41.4%

    31.6 wAV, of pick 1

  • Pick 32 · Fitzgerald–Spielberger

    41.5%

    1,244 of 3,000

  • Pick 32 · Jimmy Johnson

    19.7%

    590 of 3,000

0255075100
13264128192224

Pick 32: Teamistry AV 41.4% · Fitzgerald–Spielberger 41.5% · Jimmy Johnson 19.7%

PickTeamistry wAVShare of pick 1JohnsonFitzgerald–Spielberger
176.2100.0%100.0%100.0%
1640.553.1%33.3%53.2%
3231.641.4%19.7%41.5%
3331.240.9%19.3%40.9%
6522.429.4%8.8%29.5%
9717.322.7%3.7%22.7%
12913.617.9%1.4%17.9%
16110.814.1%0.9%14.2%
1938.411.1%0.5%11.1%

Each line is divided by its own value at pick 1, so the three charts share a scale. The Johnson chart drops much faster than the careers did. Fitzgerald–Spielberger, built from the second contracts of 2011–2015 picks, lands almost on the AV curve at pick 32.

The drawing stops at pick 224, where the Johnson table ends. The fitted curve is still defined after that.